Question 310
Assurance is requested for the following security issue: A new auditor acknowledges policy email yet lacks the skills to evaluate control evidence. Which specific outcome best validates the response?
Explanation
Correct Answer
Assessment records show personnel can reliably perform assigned security-sensitive tasks. This is the relevant test result for the scenario in which a new auditor acknowledges policy email yet lacks the skills to evaluate control evidence. It verifies the action to evaluate role-specific competence separately from general security awareness. The corresponding operating design is to define skills needed per role, provide practical training and assess demonstrated capability. The result should rule out the error of assuming attendance or policy acknowledgment alone proves operational competence.
Incorrect Answers
Access tests show unrelated users cannot retrieve customer records and authorized users still can. This may be a useful result for confidentiality protection choice in another case, such as when an insurer transfers claim summaries among partners, but the access model permits unrelated brokers to read them. It does not establish effectiveness of the controls necessary for the described problem. The relevant evidence is that assessment records show personnel can reliably perform assigned security-sensitive tasks. Case: A new auditor acknowledges policy email yet lacks the skills to evaluate control evidence.
Reported performance shows progress toward a defined security outcome rather than meeting attendance. This may be a useful result for security objective versus activity in another case, such as when a school district declares that its objective is to publish a password poster once a year. It does not establish effectiveness of the controls necessary for the described problem. The relevant evidence is that assessment records show personnel can reliably perform assigned security-sensitive tasks. Case: A new auditor acknowledges policy email yet lacks the skills to evaluate control evidence.
Reconciliation reveals approved changes and detects unauthorized or malformed data modifications. This may be a useful result for integrity preservation controls in another case, such as when a payroll team finds that approved salary entries are silently altered during a nightly import. It does not establish effectiveness of the controls necessary for the described problem. The relevant evidence is that assessment records show personnel can reliably perform assigned security-sensitive tasks. Case: A new auditor acknowledges policy email yet lacks the skills to evaluate control evidence.





PECB Certified ISO/IEC 27001 Lead Implementer (Lead Implementer) Practice Tests