Question 230
An independent privacy review team is given a comparable case at a separate client engagement. The supplied case facts are: A consumer withdraws a previously valid opt-in for optional personalised offers but the controller tells them withdrawal has no effect. Which legal reasoning best supports that response for the stated facts?
Explanation
Correct Answer
This explains the applicable privacy-law treatment in the separate assurance-review file. The practical consequence is to stop future processing that depends solely on withdrawn consent while preserving the legality of prior operations. The finding specifically concerns: A consumer withdraws a previously valid opt-in for optional personalised offers but the controller tells them withdrawal has no effect.
Incorrect Answers
The suggested legal explanation concerns a different privacy-law situation: An outsourced processor appoints a new subprocessor handling the same EU customer records without the controller's required authorisation. In the separate assurance-review file, the case file instead describes: A consumer withdraws a previously valid opt-in for optional personalised offers but the controller tells them withdrawal has no effect. For this specific issue, the governing distinction is: Article 7(3) permits withdrawal at any time; withdrawal does not retroactively invalidate earlier lawful processing. Therefore this alternative would not directly meet the stated assessment need.
The suggested legal explanation concerns a different privacy-law situation: A storage provider transmits EU customer records without encryption and has no compensating protection assessment. In the separate assurance-review file, the case file instead describes: A consumer withdraws a previously valid opt-in for optional personalised offers but the controller tells them withdrawal has no effect. For this specific issue, the governing distinction is: Article 7(3) permits withdrawal at any time; withdrawal does not retroactively invalidate earlier lawful processing. Therefore this alternative would not directly meet the stated assessment need.
The suggested legal explanation concerns a different privacy-law situation: A controller selects a customer-data processor based only on price and signs a contract with no processing instructions, confidentiality or deletion clauses. In the separate assurance-review file, the case file instead describes: A consumer withdraws a previously valid opt-in for optional personalised offers but the controller tells them withdrawal has no effect. For this specific issue, the governing distinction is: Article 7(3) permits withdrawal at any time; withdrawal does not retroactively invalidate earlier lawful processing. Therefore this alternative would not directly meet the stated assessment need.





Certified Information Privacy Professional/Europe (CIPP/E) (CIPP-E) Practice Tests