Question 110
An independent privacy review team is given a comparable case at a separate client engagement. The supplied case facts are: An EU clinic plans to use identifiable patient diagnoses for a new research use and checks only a generic Article 6 legitimate interest. Which legal reasoning best supports that response for the stated facts?
Explanation
Correct Answer
This explains the applicable privacy-law treatment in the separate assurance-review file. The practical consequence is to assess both an Article 6 lawful basis and an applicable Article 9 condition for health-data processing. The finding specifically concerns: An EU clinic plans to use identifiable patient diagnoses for a new research use and checks only a generic Article 6 legitimate interest.
Incorrect Answers
The suggested legal explanation concerns a different privacy-law situation: A processor discovers unauthorised access to a client's personal-data backups but sends only a message to its own public-relations team. In the separate assurance-review file, the case file instead describes: An EU clinic plans to use identifiable patient diagnoses for a new research use and checks only a generic Article 6 legitimate interest. For this specific issue, the governing distinction is: Health data are special-category data and require an Article 9 exception in addition to a lawful basis where GDPR applies. Therefore this alternative would not directly meet the stated assessment need.
The suggested legal explanation concerns a different privacy-law situation: A storage provider transmits EU customer records without encryption and has no compensating protection assessment. In the separate assurance-review file, the case file instead describes: An EU clinic plans to use identifiable patient diagnoses for a new research use and checks only a generic Article 6 legitimate interest. For this specific issue, the governing distinction is: Health data are special-category data and require an Article 9 exception in addition to a lawful basis where GDPR applies. Therefore this alternative would not directly meet the stated assessment need.
The suggested legal explanation concerns a different privacy-law situation: An access request reaches the controller, but staff insist that all GDPR rights requests always take three months before any reply. In the separate assurance-review file, the case file instead describes: An EU clinic plans to use identifiable patient diagnoses for a new research use and checks only a generic Article 6 legitimate interest. For this specific issue, the governing distinction is: Health data are special-category data and require an Article 9 exception in addition to a lawful basis where GDPR applies. Therefore this alternative would not directly meet the stated assessment need.





Certified Information Privacy Professional/Europe (CIPP/E) (CIPP-E) Practice Tests