Question 460
A tool call to a provider returns a structured permission denied error, while another tool successfully reads public metadata. What should the coordinator conclude?
Explanation
Correct Answer
Report two distinct observed outcomes: the public metadata lookup succeeded, while the protected provider request returned permission denied. Preserve each tool's identifier, source and access status so the coordinator can use only the authorized fields. If the task requires private content, request legitimate access or provide a qualified partial answer; do not guess what the denied resource contains. This prevents a successful harmless read from masking an access-control failure and keeps the user informed about precisely which evidence is and is not available.
Incorrect Answers
A successful public-metadata read establishes only the fields that endpoint returned; it does not prove the assistant was permitted to read restricted underlying content. Inferring private data from a public title or description could invent facts and bypass the provider's denied access boundary. Keep the restricted request's actual permission error and report that private content remains unavailable. Separate independent tool results rather than turn one public success into authorization for another protected resource.
Trying the restricted request under another connected account without explicit authorization would be an access-control workaround, not a justified retry. The provider returned permission denied for the current principal and target; changing identity merely to get around the denial may violate tenant policy. Preserve the error, determine whether an authorized owner can grant access, and stop repeated prohibited attempts. A public metadata success does not supply consent to probe private data with unrelated credentials.
The fact that a document title or public index record is visible does not mean its full contents are public. Search services often expose limited metadata while requiring separate privileges for files or attachments. Treat the restricted payload as inaccessible until the provider grants a permitted read. Assuming public access from a metadata response would collapse two security levels and risk unsupported assertions or unauthorized follow-up operations.



Claude Certified Architect - Foundations (CCA-F) Practice Tests