Question 380
A contract parser extracts a monetary amount but the source contains two incompatible totals on different pages. How should validation handle the conflict?
Explanation
Correct Answer
Flag both incompatible totals with their exact page and clause references, and identify what prevents the parser from determining which is authoritative. A controlling amendment, effective-date rule or signed schedule may resolve the disagreement; otherwise escalate it for source-level review. Do not average, silently drop or choose the larger value. Validation should keep the output in a disputed state until the accepted total can be traced to an actual governing document span, then re-run reconciliation on the corrected record.
Incorrect Answers
Averaging incompatible contract totals produces a third figure that neither source page actually states. The documents may represent different amendments, effective dates or billing bases, so arithmetic compromise is not source resolution. Preserve the exact amounts, page citations and apparent conflict, then identify which clause or signed amendment controls. If the governing total cannot be established, flag the contract field as disputed instead of inventing a blended amount.
Omitting the contradiction and marking extraction complete hides a material source uncertainty. Downstream legal or financial decisions might rely on whichever amount the model happened to choose first, even though another authoritative-looking page disagrees. The validator must retain both source spans and require explicit precedence or expert clarification. A clean JSON record is not evidence that the conflicting contract terms were reconciled correctly.
The larger amount is not automatically the controlling contract value. It might be a previous proposal, an uncapped estimate or a superseded schedule, while a smaller figure could be the signed current total. Risk aversion is not a rule for selecting between documentary facts. Compare effective dates, signatures, cross-references and amendment terms before adopting one. If the pages remain inconsistent, preserve the uncertainty and request an authorized resolution.



Claude Certified Architect - Foundations (CCA-F) Practice Tests